SaskCanola

Make SaskCanola my home page

 
 
News & Events Photo Photo
Home About SaskCanola Growing & Selling Your Canola News & Events Research Industry Trends Canola in the Community Contact For Food Lovers Information for Buyers
In This Section
Latest News
Events
Press Releases
Videos & Webinars
Publications & Podcasts
SaskCanola Annual Report
Archive

 

    

Story Posted: February 09, 2011

Growers to Benefit from Next Generation Canola Variety Testing

A next generation canola variety testing program is moving forward this year to serve the needs of canola growers. The initiative, a result of extensive consultations, will involve most of the seed industry.

The approximately $1 million program will be funded by the three Prairie canola grower groups - Saskatchewan Canola Development Commission (SaskCanola), Alberta Canola Producers Commission (ACPC), and the Manitoba Canola Growers Association (MCGA), as well as by seed trade entry fees. The Canola Council of Canada (CCC) will coordinate the program as a service to growers.

"I am very grateful for the open and positive approach of all stakeholders in this process," says Denise Maurice, CCC vice-president of Crop Production. "I am confident that the new program will fulfill the objectives that growers have had from the outset."

The objective of the new variety testing program is to provide growers with the information they need to make informed seed selection choices based on:

  • a systematic approach
  • trials based on commercially available varieties
  • trials consistent with actual grower practices
  • third-party credibility
  • economic analysis based on contribution margin

In order to meet these criteria, the protocol for the program will involve two components: small plots that will examine relative performance of commercial varieties, and an audited field scale component based on field trials conducted by seed companies.

The small plots component will involve both varieties with the greatest market share and newly-introduced varieties used with the corresponding herbicide systems that are also commercially available to growers. Management of the small plots will address some of the shortcomings of former trials through plot design, data delivery and harvest management.

"What we like about this new program is that it is truly representative of the commercial varieties that are available to growers, and reflective of the actual production practices most commonly used in western Canada," says SaskCanola chair Brett Halstead. "Another important component is that the corresponding herbicides will be used."

The field scale component will involve a review of the seed trade field scale projects through an audit of the protocols being used for constructing the trial data analysis and reporting. The development of the audit process will involve qualified statisticians and professionals with extensive background in conducting field scale research trials.

"Including the seed trade field scale projects will be an added service to growers," says ACPC chair Jody Klassen. "It's not about imposing a protocol on them. It's about ensuring their protocols are based on sound science so that the data accurately represents performance."

Small plot and field scale data will be presented separately. Detailed reporting will include site specific data on weather, soil type, previous crop, fertility, seeding date and rate, harvest date etc. Print copies will be published and a web based application housed on the grower association websites and CCC website. The data will continue to be reported in the provincial seed guides.

"This is good news for our growers," says MCGA President Rob Pettinger. "Seed is a major investment for farmers and this new program will give them the information they need to make informed individual decisions that suit their particular operations."

A governance body will be established shortly to oversee the program, and to provide a mechanism for evaluating success and making improvements to protocols in the future. The governance body will be charged with resolving details around data analysis and reporting. Membership will include growers, provincial specialists, the seed trade and the CCC.

I have been very impressed by the participation of the seed trade throughout the consultations," says Maurice. "They have brought nuances to the discussion that has added great insight into many issues. There has been a great spirit of participation."

 

Background

The next generation program for canola variety testing is based on the Canola Council of Canada's (CCC) extensive consultations with canola grower groups and the seed trade.

The intention of the discussion was to establish a new variety testing program based on sound science and representative of the commercial varieties and production practices most commonly used in western Canada.

In the Fall/Winter of 2009, input and feedback was obtained from both the seed trade and grower groups. Grower groups expressed a clear need for variety testing and reporting.

Variety performance data is the number one ranked agronomic information that farmers view as essential to the effective operation of their businesses. A survey conducted in January 2010 of 1,359 growers found that variety data was the third most important information need, superseded only by weather and commodity prices.

Objectives
In consultation with grower groups the following objectives were proposed for the development of a next generation prairie-wide canola variety performance testing program:

  • a systematic approach
  • trials based on commercially available varieties
  • trials consistent with actual grower practices
  • third-party credibility
  • economic analysis based on contribution margin

Funding and Governance
A soon-to-be-established governance body will be responsible the management of the next generation canola variety testing program, including naming the program, selection of varieties, protocol design, financial management and data collection, analysis and reporting.

An agreement will be developed with all parties involved to establish rules of engagement.

The governance body will consist of:

  • 3 grower group representatives
  • 3 provincial oilseed specialists
  • 3 Canadian Seed Trade Association representatives
  • 1 CCC representative from the CCC (V-P, Crop Production - Non-voting chair)

Funding will consist of:

  • grower contributions based on the number of small field sites in each province
  • seed trade entry fees

Project Details
The protocol for the variety testing program will be combination of small plots that examine commercial varieties in conjunction with an audited field scale component.

For 2011, site distribution will be representative of seeded acres in Manitoba, Saskatchewan, and Alberta. This will generate enough information to ensure that the data is statistically representative while accounting for some site loss.

More sites can be added in subsequent years under the direction of the governance body.

The small plots component will involve only commercially available varieties. The total number of varieties will be determined by the number of top commercial varieties in the test and the number of varieties that each company would contribute. The top commercial variety will be determined by the market share data obtained from the previous year.

Management of the small plots will address some of the shortcomings of former trials through plot design, data delivery and harvest management. Specifically:

  • All varieties will be treated with the commercial associated herbicide and seed treatment.
  • Field inspections of all trials will be conducted just after the herbicide application and it will be conducted by an independent third party.
  • Harvest management is an important consideration due to the wide range of maturity in a single test. Blocking similar maturing varieties in trials comparison protocol would assist in the logistics of the harvest. Although this approach requires more resources, it is necessary to minimize harvest losses due to maturity differences.
  • A central coordinator will oversee all the sites.

For seed trade field scale research, a protocol will be developed and an audit process so that growers have confidence that the protocol was conducted in a scientifically sound manner and that comparison is appropriate.

Data Collection and Reporting
Data will be collected on the usual characteristics such as yield, height, lodging, and maturity.

Disease rating (blackleg) will be requested from the Western Canada Canola Rapeseed Recommending Committee to include in reports.

At a few select sites additional data will be collected such as growing degree days, pod shatter/drop, sclerotinia infection, vigor assessment and or ground cover. These sites will be located near research institutions where additional research is being conducted on these parameters.

Detailed reporting will include site specific data on weather, soil type, previous crop, fertility, seeding date and rate, harvest date etc. Print copies will be published and a web based application housed on the grower association websites and CCC website. The data will continue to be reported in the provincial seed guides.

 

« Back to main Latest News page

Contact SaskCanola Contact SaskCanola Click to email SaskCanola hello Site Map Privacy & Terms of Use
SmartSite by Arxus SaskCanola SCDC hi hi hello